Index of Album Reviews | George Graham's Home Page | What's New on This Site

The Graham Album Review #1857

CD graphic
Click on CD Cover for Audio Review in streaming mp3 format

Trashcan Sinatras: Wild Pendulum
by George Graham

(Independent release As broadcast on WVIA-FM 5/11/2016)

There is a good deal of retro music about, much of it by young musicians who were net yet born when the styles they draw upon were at their height. There is also still a fair number of musicians who whose careers are long enough that was is now retro was current when they were starting out. Then there are those who have been doing retro music for a long time even though they were not part of the original wave. We have an example this week, an entertaining new album of melodic Sixties-influenced pop by the Trashcan Sinatras, called Wild Pendulum.

The Trashcan Sinatras formed in Scotland in 1987, with one of its members from the start being Frank Reader, the brother of Scottish vocalist Eddi Reader. Originally a cover band, Trashcan Sinatras transitioned to doing original music and were signed to a record label, which released their debut album called Cake in 1990, which received some critical acclaim at the time. They released two more recordings during the 1990s, and then in 2000 came to the US to work on what would become their album Weightlifting, which was not released until 2004. During that time the band went through a number of difficulties, including apparently financial, and its members became separated for extended periods. But by then, the band was working independently and using the Internet to develop a fan base and to distribute their music including some special material for their fans, on the Web. They issued an acoustic album called Fez to fans in 2005, and five years later a studio project called In the Music.

In keeping with the band's Internet affinity, they turned to their fans for crowd-funding their new album called Wild Pendulum, which is now out. The group became bi-continental when bassist Frank Divanna from Los Angeles joined the otherwise Scottish band. Perhaps as a compromise, Trashcan Sinatras recorded the new album in Omaha, Nebraska, possibly to take in the Midwest Indie rock scene with artists like Conor Oberst.

What the Trashcan Sinatras come up with on the new album is an interesting mixture of 1960s pop ingredients with influence by groups like the Association and some of the arrangement quirks of Bert Bacharach, and even some doo-wop influence, with a strong emphasis on a melodic sound. But there is a kind of intertwined influence from contemporary indie rock with its occasional tendency toward getting atmospheric. One can hear a string section and some female backing vocals that at times can be reminiscent of the soundtrack to some 1960s movie. The result is pleasant but a little quirky. It's also not the most coherent sounding mixture, with musical elements and borrowed arrangement ideas sometimes seeming to be just thrown together to see what comes out, and at others, it's quite successful and imaginative. The group has been known for their lyrical wordplay, and there is more of it on the new album, along with some guests like a string quartet. Interestingly, with the retro sound of some of the added parts, they go and take it out of context by using those 1960s-sounding bits as samples giving a kind of jarring effect. But overall, it's a fun album.

Wild Pendulum opens with one of its sonic melanges, Let Me Inside (Or Let Me Out) with lots of art-rock, neo-psychedelic type things thrown in, along with strong vocal harmonies. <<>>

One of the most appealing, tuneful songs is Best Days on Earth which has elements of various 1960s pop groups, which sometimes reminds me of the old band The Association. <<>>

More toward the rock side, but with still with a decidedly retro sound is a track called Ain't That Something. <<>>

The Trashcan Sinatras also bring in influence from the more, shall we say, “saccharine” areas of pop in the 1960s. I Want to Capture Your Heart is in the full sweet mode complete with the swirling string arrangements. <<>>

The mixing of retro ingredients gets into a somewhat sonically confused jumble on the track In a Family Way, which has all kinds of things thrown in, but is quite a good composition. <<>>

The mellow side of the album comes out on a piece called The Neighbor's Place which has a largely acoustic arrangement that can hint at some of the Beatles material that in turn was influenced by English music hall. <<>>

For me, the best of the Trashcan Sinatras' retro stew comes on Waves (Sweep Away My Melancholy). There's even some harpsichord sound that was pervasive in a lot of mid 1960s pop, but this is one instance in which the mixed up sound comes together very well. <<>>

The album ends with a mostly acoustic ballad called I See the Moon, which is a nice, musically contemplative touch to end this album of somewhat dense sounding pop. <<>>

Wild Pendulum, the new release by the nearly 30-year-old band Trashcan Sinatras, is a fun record of retro music from a group that has been doing this sort of thing since it was not quite as retro. It's the first from the group in six years and they apparently brought along a lot of ideas. The retro touches, many from the quirkier side of 1960s pop and psychedelia, are at times charming and at others a bit of a mess. They also bring in some of the contemporary Indie rock touches such as the atmospheric quality to the sound. The band's songwriting is first rate throughout, and their vocals, with Frank Reader the main lead vocalist, get it just right.

For our sound quality grade, we'll be merciful and give it a C-minus. The mix is generally good with allowances for the retro stuff. But the overall sound is badly over compressed, even for pop, to make it loud all the time, with little dynamics and an overly in-your-face sound that gets fatiguing after a while.

There's no shortage of retro pop on the scene these days, but Trashcan Sinatras bring their own often-clever twist to it, and make another worthwhile recording that is likely to please their fans and the critics.

(c) Copyright 2016 George D. Graham. All rights reserved.
This review may not be copied to another Web site without written permission.

<<>> indicates audio excerpt played in produced radio review

Comments to George:

To Index of Album Reviews | To George Graham's Home Page. | What's New on This Site.

This page last updated [an error occurred while processing this directive]