Index of Album Reviews | George Graham's Home Page | What's New on This Site

The Graham Weekly Album Review #1608

CD graphic
Click on CD Cover for Audio Review in streaming mp3 format
Stuart Robertson: Years Between Us
by George Graham

(Primesound 20104 As broadcast on WVIA-FM 8/25/2010)

Though he was little known outside a small circle of fans and other artists during his lifetime, the late British singer-songwriter Nick Drake continues to have a lasting influence. He died at age 26 in 1974, and while he was alive, none of his albums sold more than 5000 copies each. But his literate, introspective, sometimes jazzy songs with distinctive lyrics, and his quiet, memorable vocals continue to find new audiences among successive generations. Drake's influence has been especially felt among other artists. For example the Dream Academy's 1985 hit Life in a Northern Town was about Drake. In recent years, Drake's music has turned up in television commercials, which gave him a whole new audience.

On this album review series, we noted Drake's influence on Duncan Sheik, whose album Phantom Moon was unabashedly inspired by Drake, using the influence in a very creative way.

This week, we have a new recording by performer who also takes some inspiration from the sound and style of Nick Drake. It's Stuart Robertson, whose new third studio album is called Year Between Us.

Stuart Robertson is 36 years old and from Scotland, born in Edinburgh, and not much else about him has been published. He released his debut album, The Furthest Shelter in 2005, involving musicians from both sides of the Atlantic. His previous recording was a limited edition live CD and download album in 2008 called This Cold Inside. He has apparently developed a following in Portugal, where he has performed a number of times.

Unlike Nick Drake, Robertson is a pianist, and most of his songs are piano-based. The new CD is perhaps a bit more laid-back in sound than his previous recordings. The instrumentation is somewhat sparser. In keeping with Robertson's reticence, the new CD lacks any musicians' credits, leaving one guessing whether this was a one-man effort. Robertson lists himself as producer.

His songs tend to be lyrically vague, allowing the listener to infer what they will from them, though there are also some more straight-ahead love lyrics, and despite the small backing group, some of the tracks feature extended instrumental interludes.

Opening is one of the most appealing tracks on the CD I Have Been Bad, which a cross between 1960s bossa nova and the melancholy Nick Drake sensibility. <<>>

Another highlight of the album comes next: The Room Did Not Agree combines an interesting, but sparse musical context with intriguing, contemplative lyrics. <<>>

A song called Slipping appears twice on the CD in different versions. The first has nominally a full band, though it's pretty laid-back. The song's lyrical refrain shows Robertson's gift for the ambiguous but profound. <<>>

There is what is called the "piano version" of Slipping which is added as a kind of bonus track at the end. But the treatment of the song is rather different in mood as well as instrumentation and running time.

The title song Years Between Us is another worthwhile piece of writing. After the rather opaque lyrics, the piece gets into an extended, somewhat atmospheric section. <<>>

With the added string sounds, Robertson's song Here is also nicely done and is somewhat reminiscent of Duncan Sheik's take on the Nick Drake influence. <<>>

The CD is arranged with the stronger material toward the beginning. What I suppose could be described as the "filler material" comes in the latter third. While song Sleeping Here has Robertson's typically interesting lyrics, the repetitious music negates that. Maybe it's because Robertson's main instrument, the piano, is missing. <<>>

Also atmospheric in sound and based on a stripped down lyrical approach is Get Me <<>> which builds into a kind of ethereal jam. <<>>

Scottish singer-songwriter pianist Stuart Robertson's new CD Years Between Us is an intelligent and enjoyable recording by an artists who shows the Nick Drake imprint, not that that's anything to complain about. As a pianist, Robertson is obviously going to have a different sound than Drake who played a classical-style guitar. But the laid-back, largely acoustic sound, the interesting compositional touches and the intriguingly ambiguous lyrics come together well to make one of those albums that is both enjoyable and that holds one's attention.

Our grade for sound quality is about a B-plus. It sounds as if it was recorded in a modestly-equipped studio, but the mix is well-done. Like most CDs these days, the sound was needlessly compressed, killing the dynamic range of this often-sensitive music.

In his day, Nick Drake sold few records. He was never a "pop" artist. But his influence lives on though his durable music that crosses generations. Likewise, Stuart Robertson's Years Between Us is unlikely to get anywhere near the top of the commercial pop charts. But it's also music that in its own quiet way, has a lot of appeal and staying power.

(c) Copyright 2010 George D. Graham. All rights reseved.
This review may not be copied to another Web site without written permission.

<<>> indicates audio excerpt played in produced radio review

Comments to George:

To Index of Album Reviews | To George Graham's Home Page. | What's New on This Site.

This page last updated August 03, 2014