Index of Album Reviews | George Graham's Home Page | What's New on This Site

The Graham Album Review #1866

CD graphic
Click on CD Cover for Audio Review in streaming mp3 format

Jacob Collier: In My Room
by George Graham

(Membran Records As broadcast on WVIA-FM 8/10/2016)

There are a lot of musicians out there plying their trade, many of them very good, some of them innovative. And then there are those who are one of a kind, seeming to emerge fully formed at a young age. We have such a rare bird this week. It’s Jacob Collier whose debut album is called In My Room. It’s a wild mix of multiply layered vocals and jazz influence along the lines of Bobby McFerrin and a quirky collection of instrumentation, which manifests itself as what I used to call an “ear grabber” record.

Jacob Collier is a Londoner, who was 21 at the recording of his album at the end of last year and start of this year, though he looks about 14. His album shows remarkable sophistication both musically and sonically. But this did not suddenly appear. He grew up, and apparently still lives in a house full of music. His mother is an active classical music teacher. His family has lived in the same house for generations and there has always been a music room, Collier writes, for 110 years, full of instruments, and where his mother teaches students. He said that his earliest memories are of hearing his mother play Bach on the violin when he was a toddler. His whole family plays music and sings together, and Collier sang in classical chorus. He also cites Stevie Wonder as a major influence. So young Jacob grew up in that music room and would end up spending most of his time in there, learning the instruments and experimenting with music creation software. About five years ago, he started doing creative reworkings of pop songs with multiple overdubbed vocals and instrumental sounds he created often by fusing together the sounds of found objects. Interestingly, Collier was also a child actor, appearing in as Tiny Tim in the film “A Christmas Carol (The Movie),” and on stage as one of the three boys in Mozart’s opera “The Magic Flute.”

In 2011, Collier began sharing some of the videos he had created with his multiply overdubs covers of song like Pure Imagination and Stevie Wonder’s Isn’t She Lovely, which attracted a lot of attention including among from some well-known musicians such as Quincy Jones. He also caught the eye of researchers at the famous Media Lab at MIT who helped Collier to create a live version of his layered compositions and an electronic harmony device which allowed him to do the vocal harmonies in real time on a keyboard. Also earlier this year, Collier appeared on the latest album by the eclectic ensemble Snarky Puppy, which we also reviewed.

For his debut album, Collier retreated into his music room and created all the voices and instrumental sounds by himself, sometimes with what sounds like dozens of layers of overdubs. He also does mostly original music after making his mark with his creative video covers. The result is quite remarkable. There are the vocal acrobatics of Bobby McFerrin along with some of his whimsy, there is clear Stevie Wonder influence, and he shows his fascination with jazz which he came to somewhat later in life, like at age 15. And there are just the unexpected things that happen when someone who lived and breathed music since being a toddler spends most of his time holed up in a room full of instruments and is obsessed with sounds.

Opening is a piece called Woke Up Today which epitomizes the hyper-eclectic sound of Collier and his music, with a raggedy funk rhythm consisting of miscellaneous sounds sampled into virtual percussion instruments, with Collier creating his vocal chorus. <<>> Like most of Collier’s tunes, the piece veers off in clever, surprising and in this case, jazzy directions. <<>>

The Beach Boys’ In My Room is a natural to include in this album which is so much the product of Collier’s music room. It’s a nice version with the densely layered vocals, more so even than a Beach Boys record, and a percussion sound consisting of things like knocking on the the floor and a sauce pan lid. <<>>

Along the same lyrical lines is Hideaway, done with a sparse but atmospheric instrumental backup including some acoustic guitar. <<>>

Sounding a bit like a more standard jazz ballad is Collier’s arrangement of a tune by one of his biggest influences, Stevie Wonder, You and I, with some excellent vocal arranging. <<>>

However, the Stevie Wonder influence really comes to the fore on an original called Saviour. Again it’s a mixture of vocal acrobatics with grooves constructed with combinations of unconventional sounds. <<>>

One of the most musically interesting pieces on the album is an original called Hajanga, in which Collier says he wanted to convey the effect of spinning in circles. <<>>

The most straight-out fun track on the album and also one of the most impressive, is one of the covers. Collier does an amazing mostly a cappella version of the theme from the old cartoon series The Flintstones. <<>> Then in the midst of all of that, Collier throws in a solo on a melodica, a kind of keyboard harmonica. <<>>

With all the layered vocal parts that dominate this album, Collier does a very attractive ballad called In The Real Early Morning, which is mainly just keyboard and his solo vocal. <<>>

Most of Jacob Collier’s 21 years have been leading up to this album, spending much of his time in his family’s hereditary music room, exploring and experimenting, along with the inevitable practicing. Still, the album comes as a kind of sonic bolt from the blue, a real “ear-grabber” in a day in which there are so few really original sounds about. Collier has already been attracting attention with his clever videos usually showing six or as many as 14 versions of the boyish Collier singing the parts on screen. While his music has some overlap with soul, R&B and jazz, the level of musical sophistication puts it up there with some serious art rock. The first few times one listens there is likely to be a jaw-dropping reaction, and after that, it’s an appreciation for the combination of the originality and the painstaking craftsmanship that went into the record. Those with long memories might remember Mike Oldfield in the 1970s, creating such elaborate music by himself, toiling away solitary in the studio. But of course, Oldfield’s music was quite different. And though Collier did create this album by himself, he does perform live with others and as mentioned puts in a guest appearance on the newest Snarky Puppy album, and has recorded with the WDR jazz big band in Germany.

Our grade for sound quality is an “A.” Collier has an appreciation for sonic clarity and for all the layering and some pitch shifting on his vocals, the sound remains clean and undistorted. And the dynamic range, how the recording maintains the differences between loud and soft is far better than the average CD today.

Last week in our review of Sarah Jarosz’ latest recording, we talked about how musical prodigies have evolved as they get older. In a recent interview, Jacob Collier spoke of constantly moving ahead and noting how he has changed since just a couple of years ago. It will be interesting to hear the further evolution of this remarkable artist. Until then, his album In My Room is most impressive, and one of the creative standouts of the year.

(c) Copyright 2016 George D. Graham. All rights reserved.
This review may not be copied to another Web site without written permission.

<<>> indicates audio excerpt played in produced radio review

Comments to George:

To Index of Album Reviews | To George Graham's Home Page. | What's New on This Site.

This page last updated August 14, 2016